A scene from 'Spy Game'
Courtesy Photo
*** stars 126 minutes | Rated: R
Opened: Friday, November 21, 2001
Directed by Tony Scott

Starring Robert Redford, Brad Pitt, Catherine McCormack, Marianne Jean-Baptiste, Stephen Dillane, Larry Bryggman, Charlotte Rampling


Being largely character-driven, "Spy Game" survives well on the small screen. But don't get distracted. There are several small but important details and performance nuances that go by in a flash.

   VIDEO RELEASE: 04.09.2002
Packed with features including an excellent, fantastically detailed commentary track by director Tony Scott, who has a lot to say about working with Pitt & Redford, about stylistic and editing choices, about the shoot itself and about how world politics effected the making of the film (including the war in Israel and Sept. 11). Yet he does all this without talking non-stop, often taking a breather to watch a scene or two himself. Extras include as-you-watch features (click on icons that pop up for more info during the movie), a second commentary by the producers, and several deleted & extended scenes w/ commentary (some of which include backstory between Redford & McCormack that's only hinted at in the final cut). One annoying problem: The alternate and deleted scenes cannot be accessed seperately on the disc.

ONE BIG PROBLEM: Once you turn on the as-you-watch, click-for-more feature, you can't turn it off, and it includes subtitles for some reason. Very annoying. What's worse, nothing ever pops up to click on for more info! Depending on the DVD player you're using (especially PC and Mac DVD software), you may never be able to turn off the subtitles after turning them on once.

Interesting 3m featurette with Scott about his storyboarding process.

2.35;1 ratio; 5.1 Dolby, 5.1 DTS
DUBS: French
SUBS: Spanish, English
Clean & clear.



Title: (optional)
 LINKS for this film
Official site
at Rotten Tomatoes
at Internet Movie Database
Redford stars as a CIA spook engineering an unathorized rescue in sly but overly slick 'Spy Game'

By Rob Blackwelder

Plied with borderline-implausible layers of CIA subterfuge and ensconced in director Tony Scott's flashy, superficial visual assault style of ostentatious MTV filmmaking, "Spy Game" is an intrigue-and-action thriller that takes you on a great ride while not really being a great movie.

Like a turbo-charged Tom Clancey adaptation, much of the film takes place inside the hallways, offices and conference rooms of CIA headquarters, circa 1991. But since Scott is a purveyor of short attention span fare, every scene is punched up to a distracting extent with circling cameras, quick edits, black-and-white freeze-frames and other cinematic amphetamines.

However, the picture is grounded by the calm, confident, sly performance of Robert Redford, starring as a veteran spook-wrangler forced to audaciously outfox his own agency to bring a man back alive.

"Spy Game" takes place in the 24 hours after retirement-bound Nathan Muir (Redford) learns that his most talented protégé, Tom Bishop (Brad Pitt), has gone rogue and been captured while trying to break someone out of a Chinese prison. He's going to be executed for espionage the next day, and the U.S. government is ready to let him swing. So on the auspices of providing some first-person background on Bishop, Muir elbows his way into a pow-wow of Agency brass to bide for time and abscond with enough classified intel to put a rescue into play.

Over the course of the marathon meeting, Muir recalls his history with Bishop, narrating a series of flashbacks from the two men's first meeting in Vietnam (where Bishop was an army sniper) to Bishop's 1976 recruitment in Berlin (arranged by Muir) and his first disillusionment with the CIA's Cold War ideals (Muir ordered him to abandon a defector who was killed the next day). Meanwhile, Muir uses every bit of expert artifice at his disposal to manipulate his superiors and co-workers as he concocts a plan on the fly and uses backdoor channels to arrange a mission right under the Agency's nose.

Herein lies another problem with "Spy Game" (besides Scott's techno-soundtrack three-ring circus of frenetic imagery): Muir is single-handedly responsible for so many security breaches in this single day that it makes the Central Intelligence Agency look like a bunch of goombahs wearing blinders.

Yet somehow watching the wheels turn in Redford's head makes it all seem credible. Even though we're not entirely sure what he's up to, we know he has a plan and we know he's risking everything -- his retirement, his nest egg, even his freedom if he gets caught -- to put it in motion.

The picture's longest flashback, set in Beirut in 1985, fills in the rest of the blanks as Bishop meets a beautiful aid worker (Catherine McCormack), who isn't what she seems, and has a hand in an assassination gone wrong that disillusions him for good with the Agency's increasingly deceitful methods.

Possibly the most significant obstacle to "Spy Game" having any real gravity to go with its spy candy sensibilities is that Bishop isn't much more than a plot device. Brad Pitt fleshes out the character's indignant idealism nicely, but Scott never gives us a glimpse of what makes him such an outstanding agent or why Muir feels such loyalty toward him. In the flashbacks he's just being molded in training montages or arguing with Muir's ends-justify-the-means defenses of CIA procedure ("You don't just trade these people like baseball cards!"). In the film's present, he just gets tortured in the shadows of the Chinese prison.

Even with its style over substance, "Spy Game" (conceived by Michael Frost Beckner, creator of the CIA-based TV series "The Agency") is always tense, vital and thrilling. On the Tony Scott scale of high-gloss quality vs. high-gloss crapola, it ranks much closer to "Crimson Tide" than it does empty vessels of cinematic cool like "Enemy of the State," "Top Gun," "Days of Thunder," "The Fan" or "The Last Boy Scout."


Buy from Amazon

Rent from Netflix

or Search for

powered by FreeFind
SPLICEDwire home
Online Film Critics Society
All Rights Reserved
Return to top
Current Reviews
SPLICEDwire Home