The Five Obstructions movie review, Jorgen Leth, Lars von Trier. Review by Rob Blackwelder ęSPLICEDwire
Rent DVDs From NetFlix Buy movies From Amazon Buy Posters From AllPosters

SPLICEDwire content is available for print, web, radio & PDA starting at just $99/month!
CINEMA SHOWDOWN
A scene from 'The Five Obstructions'
Buy movie posters at AllPosters.com
Courtesy Photo
"THE FIVE OBSTRUCTIONS"
**** stars
(In subtitled Danish, French & English)
90 minutes | Unrated
LIMITED: Friday, June 25, 2004
Directed by Jorgen Leth, Lars von Trier

Featuring Jorgen Leth, Lars von Trier



This film is on the Best of 2004 list.


 COUCH CRITIQUE
   SMALL SCREEN SHRINKAGE: 15%
   WIDESCREEN: A MUST

Hey, Leth shows von Trier the finished films on a TV. If it's good enough for them, it's good enough for us!

   VIDEO RELEASE: 10.05.2004
 DVD SPOTLIGHT
Had all six version of "The Perfect Human" been included on this DVD, it could have been a spectacular dream come true for cinephiles. Alas, Leth's 1967 original is one of the disc's few bonus features.

An existential but engrossingly simple, sometimes tongue-in-cheek primer on human beings and the meaning of humanity through some of its more curious behavior, this starkly black-and-white 13m short plays almost as if it were designed to be shown to a species unfamiliar with us. It's a brilliant piece of '60s avante-garde.

But Leth's interview-style "commentary" on the main feature (the interviewer not identified) is the only other "Obstructions"-related extra on this DVD -- and it's only interesting in fits and starts since most of what the director had to say about the project is said in the film. Its bigger problem is that this extra audio track has not been layered well on top of the film's sound, so if someone is talking on screen at the same time Leth is talking on this track, it's often hard to hear what he's saying.

OTHER NOTABLE BONUS MATERIAL
Trailers for some of the distributor's other great DVDs like "La Dolche Vita," "Jesus of Montreal" and "In July."

SOUND & PICTURE
Both are terrific, except on the original "Perfect Human," which has some bad audio -- although that seems to be intentional.


  BUY IT HERE
SPECS
Various aspect ratios
(16x9 enhanced)
DUBS: none
SUBS: English

DVD RATING: **1/2



 OTHER REVIEWS/COMING SOON
 
  • Lars von Trier


  •  LINKS for this film
    Official site (France)
    at Rotten Tomatoes
    at Internet Movie Database

     SHOWTIMES (movies.yahoo.com)
    Title: (optional)
    ZIP:
    Danish directors duke it out in a duel of wits: Leth remakes a film 5 times under von Trier's harsh artistic restrictions

    By Rob Blackwelder

    An eccentric and intrepid testament to the pure joy of cinema, "The Five Obstructions" is what happens when one of the world's most audacious filmmakers -- Las von Trier, founder of the minimalist Dogme95 movement and director of "Breaking the Waves," "Dancer in the Dark" and "Dogville" -- decides to challenge his artistic mentor to a duel of intellect and imagination.

    The semi-documentary begins with a simple conversation between von Trier and prolific Danish writer-director Jorgen Leth, in which the student presents his one-time teacher with a challenge too thought-provoking to refuse: Leth is to direct five remakes of his 1967 short "The Perfect Human," and for each version von Trier will impose creative restrictions to see if the filmmaker can rise to the occasion.

    Leth, a kindly, long-faced intellectual in his 60s, enters into the agreement enthusiastically but almost immediately comes to realize he's made a deal with the devil. The childish, egotistical von Trier delights in tormenting him with what seem like increasingly impossible hurdles.

    The illusory original "Perfect Human," glimpsed in segments over the course of this film, is a beautifully stark, crisp black-and-white film that explores in deceptively simple ways what it means to be human -- what it is to walk or talk, to dance and jump, to dress and undress, to shave, sleep, dream and eat.

    With a villainous smirk, Von Trier calls it "a little gem that we're now going to ruin." But part of what makes "The Five Obstructions" such a magnificent celebration of the cinematic art is that no matter what limits the younger filmmaker imposes upon the elder, in the almost malicious hope of tripping him up, Leth foils him at every turn.

    For the first remake, von Trier commands that no cut shall be longer than twelve frames (half of a second), that all the rhetorical questions asked in the intangible narration of "The Perfect Human" must be answered, and that the film must be shot in Cuba. Already irritated and pondering out loud about how he might even begin to shoot such a film, Leth makes the mistake of saying "I would like to build a room there, or we could use a screen..."

    "What a pity," replies von Trier. "In that case you can't do that."

    But much to von Trier's unmistakable frustration, the film Leth turns in -- after "The Five Obstructions" follows him to Cuba to document the shoot -- is a stroke of near-genius, using repeated images in a style reminiscent of stop-motion animation to re-envision "The Perfect Human" in a way that leaves the original's simplicity intact while embracing the color and culture of his location.

    Trying to up the ante for round two of their bout, von Trier demands that, among other restrictions, Leth shoot in the most miserable place he can imagine -- but that he cannot show the misery. So Leth travels to a dilapidated red-light district in a Bombay slum, and his solution to this challenge is inspired and exquisite in the way it turns the location and circumstances into an elusive, ambiguous, strangely forbidding beauty.

    Trumped again, Von Trier gets upset because he thinks Leth bent the rules (he didn't and von Trier is just being a sore loser). "So," he says, "I have to punish you somehow."

    And so it goes through three more spellbinding segments that become increasingly thorny and increasingly creative, culminating in a diabolical twist that only someone as devious and supercilious as von Trier could devise.

    To keep the film down to a brisk 90 minutes, "The Five Obstructions" shows only highlights of each "Perfect Human" remake -- which means the ultimate "Five Obstructions" experience may be seeing it in the future on an extras-packed DVD. But the wondrous imagery with which Leth defeats each obstruction justifies a trip to the theater if the option is available to you.






    Buy from Amazon
    More new releases!
    or Search for









    SEARCH SPLICEDwire
     
    powered by FreeFind
    SPLICEDwire home
    Online Film Critics Society
    ęSPLICEDwire
    All Rights Reserved
    Return to top
    Current Reviews
    SPLICEDwire Home